Home / how to write a journal article review / THE JOURNAL ARTICLE REVIEW:

THE JOURNAL ARTICLE REVIEW: - how to write a journal article review

The purpose of this assignment is to help you understand how research is conducted and reported in developmental psychology.  You are asked to read a peer-reviewed article from a scholarly journal in the field of lifespan development.  Articles of this type will typically report on original research or replications of previously conducted experiments, or they will be literature reviews in which the author(s) present the results of a literature search on a specific topic.  In the latter case, the article will usually be a dissertation on the most current thinking on a specific topic.
You can browse the periodical room of the college library for journals that pertain to human development. These can be from a medical, psychological or sociological perspective. Reference librarians are available to help with your search.
Either from home or on campus you can search for articles on EBSO Host. To access this site, start at the Library homepage, click on Articles on the left side navigation bar, and click on EBSCO Host when the list comes up. Academic Search Premier or Elite are good search engines to use. You will be directed to a search page. You should limit your search to:

Full text
Scholarly (peer reviewed) journals
Published in the past 5 years
Enter your subject in the search box and click on GO. You will generate a list of articles which can be accessed online. Some are also available in the RCC library; if this is the case, there will be a notation in the search result. You can print out your article from here.
There are probably other search engines you can use, and the reference librarian is a good resource for this information.
Also, if you have questions about the writing piece, the Writing Lab in Coates Hall is available to help. They should have examples of journal articles reviews from my General Psychology classes on file.
Or, you can come and see me during office hours, or by appointment.

Here is an example of the proper form for your journal article review. It should be two-three pages long, typed, double spaced. This goes at the top of page one; don't bother with a cover page:
Your Name
PSY 219 Date
Author(s). (year of publication). Article title. Journal name, volume, number, pages.
Wood, D. (2003). Effect of child and family poverty on child health in the United States. Pediatrics Sep2003 Supplement, Vol 112, 3, 707-712
First, summarize the article.
The subject of this article is to review the literature on the effects of poverty on children in the United States, including economic, ecologic and family influences. Poverty is defined as "a condition of misery, hopelessness and dependency." (Heclo, cited in Wood, 2003). This article examines previous writings and attempts to develop an understanding of the role the state of poverty could play in the development of the child.
Next, explain and critique the methods use and/or the findings presented.
The author selected research articles and other writings from the field for review and analysis. His methods were thorough. His intent was to integrate the findings that had already been reported into a single article that could be the starting point for future research. Wood found that…………
And finally, offer your opinion on the value of the study. Will this study further our knowledge base or the goals of psychology, i.e., to describe, explain, predict and influence behavior? What does it add to our knowledge of human development?

How to submit a review to Journal? Try to bear in mind the following questions - they'll help you form your overall impression: What is the main question addressed by the research? ... How original is the topic? ... Is the paper well written? ... Are the conclusions consistent with the evidence and arguments presented? ... If the author is disagreeing significantly with the current academic consensus, do they have a substantial case? ... More items...